Jon Aquino's Mental Garden

Engineering beautiful software jon aquino labs | personal blog

Thursday, October 15, 2026

1Password vs ProtonPass

ProtonPass API keys let me turn vaults on/off. This is good for my AI agents - I can turn my vaults on when my AI agent needs it and off when it is done. 1Password API keys does not have this ability.

Frustratingly, ProtonPass seems to ask me to go through a 3-step onboarding flow sometimes after signing in.

You lose your passkeys when you migrate from one service to another.

1Password has not only a master password that you memorize, but also a super-long secret key that stays on each device. ProtonPass just has a master password, and is thus less secure.

1Password has a handy anywhere pop-up that can be called up using Command+\. Proton Pass does not.

i believe 1Password lets me use passkeys in my desktop browser. ProtonPass does not - I need to pull out my phone to scan a qr code.

1Password's browser extension syncs with the desktop app so I can use Touch ID. ProtonPass's browser extension does not (at least not for me on Safari) - I need to enter my password or use a PIN.

2 Comments:

  • It's not exactly the same thing, but I've been playing around with 1Password's Openshell integration. You can lock down your agent to only be able to use values from a specific env file, which is a roundabout way of limiting an agent to a subset of secrets. https://www.1password.dev/get-started/secure-ai-access#keep-secrets-out-of-agent-context-with-1password-and-nvidia-openshell-beta

    I just wish they'd allow mapping an env value to a vault one so I wouldn't have to duplicate secrets

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10/19/2026 9:59 a.m.  

  • oh interesting - I'll need to check. out that openspell stuff

    By Blogger Jonathan, at 10/19/2026 10:16 a.m.  

Post a Comment

<< Home